The Problem With ‘Sustainable Journalism’ Platform Civil

ConsenSys backed “sustainable journalism” marketplace Civil isn’t raising as much as it had hoped in its ICO. Civil’s ambitious plans have been picked apart by, you guessed it,  journalists.


Free Press or Censorship

Civil’s approach to revolutionizing journalism has been questioned in a recent post by Financial Times’ AlphavilleLike many blockchain platforms, Civil’s design is based on the ever-growing concept of “crypto-economics,” reward and monetization of activities using cryptocurrency tokens or coins.

Alphaville argues that Civil’s plan to encourage participants to challenge journalism that breaches the “Civil Constitution” by staking tokens and gained the reward if the challenge is upheld, is not “free” press. Alphaville argued this is more like censorship, and questioned Civil’s CEO, Vivian Schiller, on the use of the term “free press.” Schiller agreed that “free” might need to be changed to “independent.”

Reddit Bitcoin Wizard Set To Get Own Wall Street Journal Ad Civil

The Civil Constitution includes points like “pandering to lurid curiosity” and “disclosing any political affiliations, endorsements or agendas.” So readers, or token holders first have to recognize that news might be biased, promotional, or even, dare we say it “fake.” Schiller also responded, saying the constitution is not yet finalized.

As a challenge is upheld by other token-holders and participants voting in support – what is there to stop news publishers voting tactically against competitors? What would be the incentive to vote? Civil plans to set up an arbitrating council to manage this issue, but again the problem could be the motivations of those on the council.

The Civil ICO

Civil has revised its initial goals of raising $32 million in its ICO, down to between $8 and $24 million as new ICO projects are struggling relative to the red-hot market seen at the end of 2017, with 70 percent now underwater, as BitcoinLinux recently reported. As of Wednesday, October 10, 2018, it had raised $2.1 million, with $1.1 million invested by parent company ConsenSys.

The problem could be that Civil is making it difficult for speculators, encouraging platform participants instead. NeimanLab penned a piece in September titled “How to buy into journalism’s blockchain future (in only 44 steps)” explaining the hurdles involved in buying Civil’s tokens. The ICO is set to close next week.

Admittedly, Civil has virtuous goals. A mission and new economy dedicated to journalism, “free” press, and independent newsrooms with quality reporting. Schiller explains:

Civil is a place for ethical, high-quality journalism. The Civil Constitution defines ethical journalism on Civil. People can use CVL tokens to vote and thwart bad actors or propose improvements to how it works.

The platform may yet have a few issues to work out, and the ICO results may or may not determine its success. Parent company ConsenSys is one of the largest blockchain developers in the world so it may continue to shore up the project while it gains ground. As with many blockchain projects and ICOs, Civil is a commendable proposition and another time-will-tell idea that could take off, particularly when the cryptocurrency market recovers.

Will Civil’s model work? Do you think its platform will encourage censorship or enable a more independent, free press?


Images courtesy of Shutterstock

The post The Problem With ‘Sustainable Journalism’ Platform Civil appeared first on BitcoinLinux.com.

loading…

Comments (216)

  1. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  2. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  3. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  4. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  5. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  6. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  7. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  8. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  9. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  10. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  11. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  12. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  13. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  14. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  15. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  16. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  17. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  18. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  19. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  20. Stewartjoili Oct 13, 2018
  21. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  22. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  23. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  24. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  25. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  26. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  27. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  28. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  29. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  30. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  31. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  32. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  33. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  34. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  35. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  36. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  37. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  38. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  39. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  40. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  41. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  42. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  43. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  44. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  45. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  46. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  47. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  48. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  49. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  50. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  51. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  52. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  53. MichaelTaupe Oct 13, 2018
  54. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  55. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  56. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  57. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  58. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  59. Stewartjoili Oct 13, 2018
  60. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  61. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  62. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  63. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  64. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  65. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  66. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  67. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  68. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  69. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  70. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  71. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  72. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  73. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  74. Stewartjoili Oct 13, 2018
  75. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  76. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  77. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  78. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  79. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  80. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  81. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  82. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  83. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  84. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  85. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  86. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  87. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  88. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  89. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  90. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  91. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  92. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  93. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  94. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  95. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  96. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  97. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  98. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  99. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  100. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  101. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  102. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  103. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  104. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  105. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  106. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  107. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  108. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  109. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  110. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  111. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  112. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  113. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  114. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  115. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  116. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  117. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  118. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  119. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  120. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  121. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  122. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  123. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  124. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  125. Stewartjoili Oct 13, 2018
  126. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  127. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  128. CharlesAxods Oct 13, 2018
  129. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  130. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  131. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  132. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  133. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  134. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  135. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  136. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  137. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  138. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  139. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  140. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  141. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  142. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  143. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  144. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  145. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  146. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  147. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  148. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  149. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  150. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  151. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  152. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  153. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  154. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  155. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  156. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  157. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  158. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  159. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  160. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  161. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  162. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  163. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  164. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  165. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  166. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  167. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  168. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  169. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  170. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  171. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  172. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  173. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  174. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  175. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  176. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  177. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  178. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  179. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  180. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  181. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  182. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  183. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  184. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  185. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  186. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  187. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  188. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  189. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  190. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  191. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  192. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  193. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  194. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  195. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  196. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  197. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  198. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  199. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  200. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  201. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  202. BrettMyday Oct 13, 2018
  203. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  204. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  205. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  206. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  207. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  208. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  209. Stewartjoili Oct 13, 2018
  210. Alfredaricy Oct 13, 2018
  211. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  212. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  213. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018
  214. AaronBef Oct 13, 2018
  215. BillySag Oct 13, 2018
  216. Bennyrak Oct 13, 2018

Leave a Reply